Heroic leadership

Please download to get full document.

View again

All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
 10
 
  1. By Imtiaz Ahmad 2.  Political life if ever has been marked by a tendency towards one-man rule.  This tendency has experiencedsetbacks also, and one is by no…
Related documents
Share
Transcript
  • 1. By Imtiaz Ahmad
  • 2.  Political life if ever has been marked by a tendency towards one-man rule.  This tendency has experiencedsetbacks also, and one is by no means justified in concluding an irresistible drive towards Caesarism.  Nonethelessthe resort to heroic leader has become a sufficiently common phenomenon to deserve thoughtful consideration.  Suchresort has taken place in the new and old nations as discussed in succeeding paras.
  • 3.  In new nations where dynamic leadership has enforced the following: ◦ Thrust towards modernization has often seemed to require. ◦ National discipline of a best sort. ◦ Enforced by a powerful personality.
  • 4.  In older nations where strong personal leadership is seen to be the only way needs following: ◦ To suspend divisive conflicts ◦ To avert social disintegration.
  • 5.  The question inevitably arises of the implications for a democracy due to this reliance on heroic individualwith the following reservations: ◦ How far is heroic leadership necessary and under what conditions? ◦ How far is it legitimate? ◦ Is it compatible with democracy? ◦ These are the problems that are troubling the minds of the people.
  • 6.  Most of the democratic theories have been derived from the writings of Locke under the following considerations: ◦ According to him, the people assert their rightful control over the state through a process essentially ofspontaneous radical movement. ◦ The Lockian assumption was that the people were endowed with sufficient purpose and intelligence toproduce initiatives, out of themselves. ◦ Successful revolution and effective government thereafter.
  • 7.  Conventional democratic theory accepted the Lockian bias on this matter ever after. If one defines democracy as under: ◦ A system in which the majority under constitutional procedures freely chooses among competingpersons. ◦ Limited term control of the state, then the inescapable shift of democratic theory is against investing too much significance in any particular competitor.
  • 8.  Thus democratic theory has resisted emphasis on leadership, because this emphasis seems to imply that some should lead and others should follow a proposition which clashes with the traditional democratic commitment to equality and to majoritarianism.  Moreover, it overlooks the democratic conviction that power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely.
  • 9.  Most ideologists of leadership have invoked the supposed ignorance and instability of the crowd as a chiefreason for according special respect to leaders.  Historically, the idea of leadership has been associated with elitistphilosophies; leadership theory has been a weapon employed by reactionaries of all hues against Lockiandemocracy.  The Fuhrer Prin-zip, the cult of personality, has too often led to the suppression of freedom, and the destruction of democracy.
  • 10.  Democracy, of course, does not mean weak executive, because a feeble executive means a feeble running of the government.  Both Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson stood for the strong executive by strengthening the residual of the people against the executive.
  • 11.  Democracy does not underrate the importance of great individuals who make history.  These men of historyare men of character, proven ability and sense of dedication.  An adventurer, a demagogue, a spellbinder can alsowhip up false faith; history is full of instances to of lost leaders and misplaced trust.
  • 12.  Unable to explain this phenomenon rationally, some political scientists have fashioned the theory ofcharisma.  In its original Greek sense, the word meant no more than personal magic.  Later, in Christian canonical lore,it meant the gift or grace which faith gave the believer.  Max Weber has clothed it with the habiliment of politicalconcept.
  • 13.  European philosophers were hard pressed to explain how a highly educated nation like Germany couldaccept Hitler, how the Italians accepted Mussolini.  They fell back on the theory of Charisma. They maintained thatuncertain times called forth dominant and reassuring figures.  They carried charisma.  All great men are blessed withcharisma under the following two principles: ◦ A charismatic leader does not say the time is out of joint: O cursed spite ◦ That ever I was born to set it right
  • 14.  A charismatic leader would praise Providence for setting the time out of joint so that he could set itright.  Quaid-e-Azam was one such leader.  He wore the English dress, spoke the English language but millionslistened to him in pin drop silence.  A listener was asked whether he understood what Quaid was saying “No, I don’tknow English, but I know he is saying what we all believe in,” he answered.  We all believe in democracy, butdemocracy works marvelously if we have leaders of absolute commitment and dedication to the cause of the people
  • Related Search
    We Need Your Support
    Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

    Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

    No, Thanks